The Biggest, Best Holiday Gift Guide for Absolutely Everyone On Your List in 2023!

It’s here! The gift guide to end all gift guides!!! Whatever holiday you celebrate and whoever you are shopping for, you should be able to find something on this list!

We’re following the same format as last year: starting with some general categories, like “hottest new toys,” and “last year’s best sellers,” and then moving on to categories by age with Mazzy, Harlow, Jack and Neve’s current wishlists, as well as their favorite gifts from previous years. After that, I’ve got all the categories by interest, with a heavy focus on gifts that will appeal to big kids, tweens, teens and even some young adults. And then the grown-up categories by interest for moms, dads, grandparents, friends, co-workers, etc. Although, as my kids get older, I’ve realized there is more and more overlap with the adult gifts, so don’t be afraid to peruse the whole guide to find the perfect present. For instance, your 45 year-old bestie might be a mushroom enthusiast just like Harlow.

Leah and I worked super hard on this guide (Leah even roped her friends into helping flesh out some categories one Sunday evening), so we hope you enjoy! Every year is a labor of love, but we have so much fun putting it all together and getting super creative. We worked especially hard trying to figure out some good husband and teen boy gifts, because those are always the hardest.

For full transparency, almost everything on here is from Amazon, both because it makes shopping easy and because I earn a small commission with each purchase, but please know that the time and effort we put into creating this list definitely outweighs the payment. It’s a labor of love and as some of my followers have started calling it— a public service. If you find even one gift on here that’s perfect for someone on your list, it makes it all worth it.

Let me know what your favorite gifts are in the comments! And if there is a category you think I missed, please let me know. I love a holiday gift challenge!

Rubble Crew Bow-Wow Crane Tower

Miniverse Make-It-Mini Food

Remote Controlled Barbie Corvette

Curlimals Talking Hedgehog

Gumball Machine Maker

Bitzee Virtual Pet

Lego Gear Bots

Remote Control Car that Drives on Walls

Tech Deck Skate Park

Holiday Mystery Squishmallow Squad

Up LEGO House

Fingerlings Interactive Baby Monkey

The Ultimate Bubble Gun

Splatz Squeezy Hand Soap

Mama Surprise Guinea Pig

Hover Soccer Ball

Magic Mixies Mystery Crystal Ball

Self Stacking Domino Train

Lego Ferris Wheel

PopSockets Pop Puck

Tamigotchi Party

Gabby’s Purrfect Dollhouse

Blank Comic Book Notebook

Do You Really Know Your Family Game

Instant Print Camera

Wreck This Journal

How to Draw Cute Animals

Hair Tinsel

Buddha Board

Paint Your Own Squishies

Kid Controlled Sandbox Excavator

Tabletop Shuffleboard

Razor DeltaWing Scooter

Playstation 5

Electric Unicycle

Cropped Sweatshirt

Cavalier Paint By Numbers

Winter Sonny Angel

Hello Kitty Holiday Squishmallow

Holiday Squishmallow Surprise

Cozy Socks

Bath & Body Works Strawberry Snowflake Set

Prisamacolor Drawing Lessons + Art Kit

Pineapple Skates

Hello Kitty Cosmetic Bag

Art Markers

Hello Kitty Jibbitz

Rare Beauty Highlighter

Hoverboard

Squishmallow Squad Mystery Pack

Hello Kitty Animal Crossing

Sam from Ted Lasso Funko Pop

Elf Ears

Owl House Wanted Poster

Strong Girls Book Set

Mini Stop Motion Studio

NY Giants Water Bottle

Kid’s Stunt Plane

Over the Door Basketball Hoop

Basketball PJ Pants

NY Giants Blitz Champs Card Game

NBA 2K 2024

Mario Kart Hot Wheels Track

Gaga Ball Pit

LEGO Hidden Side Castle

Beyblade Battle Arena

NFL Prestige 2022

Land of Stories Series

Mouse Trap

Baseball Bat

Brio Pinball Game

Free Throw Basketball Game

Air Hockey Tabletop Game

The Game of Life

N Necklace

Loom and Band It Book

Shrinky Dinks Mini Artist

Starry Night Lego Set

Artist Palette Pop Toy

Yayoi Kusama Doll

ABCs of Art Book

Wall Felt Play Board

Lets Go to the Museum

Picasso Wooden Montessori Play Board

Earth Themed Stickers

Garbage Truck

See-Through Compost Container

Greta and the Giants Book

Recycling + Compost Organizational Toy

Easy Peasy Gardening Book

Wheelbarrow + Garden Tools

Light Up Terrarium

Solar Race Car

Wiggling Worms at Work Book

DIY Bird 3D Wooden Puzzle

Frog Beret

Tulip Jellycat Plushie

Make Your Own Fairy Lantern

Butterfly Fairy Door

Make Your Own Potions Kit

Potion and Magical Necessities Belt

Frog Plushie

Flower Press

Natural History of Fairies

Elf Ears

Fairy Keepsake Bowl

James Webb Telescope Tee

Piece of a Meteorite

Night Sky Postcards

Star Blanket

Build Your Own James Webb Telescope Kit

Glow Moon Nightlight

Space Stickers

Magnetic Slime

Build Your Own Explorer Robot

Freeze Dried Space Food Kit

Mushroom Shelf

Harlow’s Mushroom Sweater

Mushroom Stickers

Mushroom Wicker Purse

Mushroom Vase

Mushroom Frog

Mushroom Twinkle Lights

Bracelet Auto-Threader

Rainbow Flat Clay Beads

Kids Start Up: How You Can Be an Entrepreneur Book

Letter Beads

Bracelet Stand

Black, White & Metallic Gold Beads

Elastic Bracelet String

My First Jewelry Store

Specialty Beads

Bracelet Weaver

Colorful Letter Beads

Spiderman Web Shooter Glove

Transformer Robot

Pikachu 3D Puzzle

Ninja Turtles Costume

25 Rare Pokemon Cards

Aquatic Remote Controlled Car

Miles Morales Funko Pop

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Watch

Miles Morales Lego Figurine

Remote Control Transformer Car

Strawberry Wall Decals

Create Your Own Comic Book Set

Moonlight Storybook Projector

Photo Viewer

So Many Books Socks

Writing Prompts for Kids

Color Your Own Bedtime Story Pillowcase

Before They Were Authors Childhood Biography Book

Blank Comic Book Notebook

The StoryMatic

Illustory: Create Your Own Book Kit

Create A Story Cards

101 Story Starters for Kids

CreateTV

Barbie Hat

Sol de Janeiro Pink Perfume

Kristen Ess Rose Gold Hair Temporary Spray

Guess Who Disney Princess Edition

Star Wars Droid

Encanto Karaoke Machine

Dynamic Duos 100 Year Anniversary Figurine

Wish Projector

100 Year Anniversary Mickey

Slinky Dog

Baby Yoda

Wall-e and Eve Toys

Lego Disney Ultimate Adventure Castle with All Princesses

5 Second Rule Disney Edition

Friendship Bracelet Book (+Yarn)

Black Cat Pillow

Nintendo DS + Nintendogs Game

PetsAlive Hamster Mania

The Complete Book of Dogs

Paper Swirls Kit

Make Your Own Puffy Stickers Kit

Sew Mini Treats

Elmer’s Glue Slime Kit

Make Your Own Soap Kit

DIY Headband Kit

Watercolor Set

Studio In a Box

Mosaic Nightlight Kit

Inflatable Sled Racer

Illustrated Alice in Wonderland Playing Cards

Grimm’s Illustrated Fairy Tales

Alice in Wonderland Puzzle

Ace of Spades Earrings

Compass

Alice in Wonderland “Drink Me” Tea Sampler Set

Coloring Book

Rifle Paper Co. Alice in Wonderland Hardback

Alice in Wonderland Stickers

Alice in Wonderland Nightlight

Magical Talking Tea Set

LatchKits Hook Rug Kit

Rainbow Yarn Kit

Lego Floral “Cross Stitch”

Tiny Purse

Royal Dansk Cookies (and the tin to store things in for the rest of time)

Potholder Loom

Flower Crochet Kit

Mini Keychain Cross Stitch

Giant Yarn

Cake Decorating Stand & Palatte Knives

Heart Spatula

Cake Pop Kit

Silicone Cupcake Liners

Candy Melting Pot

In The French Kitchen With Kids

Pasta Making Kits

Heart-Shaped Waffle Maker

Kids Chef Knives

What The Artist Saw: Claude Monet

Honey Sticks Crayons

Frida Kahlo and her Animalitos

Interchangable Art Frame

Light Up Tracing Pad

Spin Art Kit

Glow in the Dark Rock Painting Kit

Artist Smock

Women in Art Book

Easel

Washable Finger Paint

Sculpd Beginner Clay Kit

Sherlock Holmes Detective Dress Up Items

National Geographic Spy Science Kit

Invisible Ink Pens

Recording Pen

Enola Holmes Graphic Novel

Who Were the Navajo Code Talkers

Prediction Putty

Eyes-In-The-Back-Of-Your-Head Mirrored Aviators

Fingerprinting Kit

Code Breaker Ring

Decoder Wheel

Forensic Investigative Kit

Delft Blue Cookie Tin & Cookies

Opera Gloves

Stationary with Flower Petals

Porcelain Tea Set

Lace Fan

Jane Austen Clothbound Penguin Classics Set

Toile Peel and Stick Wallpaper

Wisteria Vines for Doorways or Above Beds

Wax Seal Kit

Regency Nightgown

Floriography: An Illustrated Guide to the Victorian Language of Flowers

Quill Pen

Harney & Son’s English Breakfast Tea

Kid’s Regency Gown

Rose Oil Eau de Toilette

Floral Embroidery Kit

Dreamers Become Doers Journaling Set

Gold Initial Bracelet

Glow Recipe Watermelon Moisturizer

Rainbow Flower Pillow

Preppy Patch Make-up Bag Set

Pink Cinema Lightbox

Nintendo Game and Watch: Legend of Zelda

National Geographic Marble Run

Book Nook 3D Model Kit

Desk Dinosaur 3D Puzzle

Smartphone Controlled Paper Airplane Kit

Make Your Own Root Beer Kit

Chess Set

Hook & Ring Game

Batman Mystery Puzzle Box

Dungeons and Dragons Dice

Smart Rubik’s Cube + App

Peace Out Acne Blemish Control

Mario Badesceu Facial Mist

Jade Roller

Get Ready With Me Headband

Supergoop Unseen Sunscreen

Starface Pimple Patches

Lighted Makeup Mirror

Oily Skin Routine

Peachy Clean Bath Mat

Elf Cleansing Balm

Green Tea Hydrating Cleanser

Winston’s Bird Shirt

New Girl Stickers

Pattern Pens for Notes/Scrapbooking

Washi Tape

Knitting Machine with Hand Crank

New Girl Bamboo Novelty Coasters

Pink Wine Glasses

Douchebag Jar Pouch

Nick Panic Moonwalking Mug

Yellow Heart Purse

Ms. Day’s JAMboree Shirt

Dragonfly Inn Keychain

Chilton Sweatshirt

“I Smell Snow” Candle

Luke’s Diner Coffee Cup

Illustrated Gilmore Girls Coffee Cup

Gilmore Girls Stickers

Gilmore Girls Cookbook

Stars Hollow Sweatshirt

Gilmore Girls Makeup Bag

Travis Kelce Jersey

Gold Hoops

Meet Me At Midnight Slippers

Eras Tour Sweatshirt

Taylor Swift Stickers

Taylor Swift Little Golden Book

Taylors Version Tote

Disco Ball Earrings

Heart Shaped Sunglasses

Glitter Boots

Champagne Problems Poster

Taylor Swift Friendship Bracelets

1989 (TV) Sweatshirt

Not a Lot Going On At The Moment Shirt

Playbill Puzzle

Bruiser Stuffie (Legally Blonde)

“Work” Pin (Hamilton)

The Wicked Grimmerie – Elphaba’s Spell Book

Break a Leg: Theater Traditions and Superstitions

I Can’t, I Have Rehearsal Mug

Broadway Costumes Poster

Cards Against Humanity Theater Expansion Pack

Playbill Wall Art

Karaoke Machine

Waitress Pie Cookbook

Burn Book Vase (Mean Girls)

I Just Really Love Musicals Tote

Warning I May Break Out Into Show Tunes Socks

Broadway Colored Pencils

Les Mis Scarf

Reusable Disposable Camera

Cows in the Meadow Sweater

Green Analogue Watch

Grecian Woman Planter

Chicken Earrings

Green Blue Light Glasses

Funky Glass Straws

12 Inch Disco Ball

Flamingo Jewelry Tray

Blue Beaded Purse

Cowboy Boot Vase

Pink/Orange/Green Sweater

DIY Clay Earrings Kit

Los Angeles Sweatshirt

Smiley Face Corduroy Tote

Pistachio Brulee Perfume

Basic Baby Tee

Baggu Crescent Bag

Digital Camera

Cropped Puffer Jacket

Blow Dryer/Styling Brush

Teleties Hair Ties

Ruffle Socks

Makeup Organizer

The Hot Sauce Challenge

Print Anything Sticker Printer

Floating Moon Nightlight

Podcasting Mic

Bluetooth Headphones

New Phone, Who Dis Game

Portable Electronic Synth, Sampler & Looper

100 Horror Movies Scratch Off Poster

Fuzzy Sneaker Slippers

Bluetooth Speaker + Water Bottle

What Do You Meme Game

Jewelry Dish

Weighted Elephant Stuffie

Candle Warmer (no fire!)

Yeti Cup for Hot/Cold Drinks

Green Checkered Fleece Blanket

Smart Connect Color Changing Light Bulb (connect it to your phone!)

Rainbow Mirrored Digital Clock

Lava Lamp

Personalized Book Blind Embosser: “From the Library Of…”

Neck Flashlight

Flower Bookmarks

Floating Bookshelves

“You Have Bewitched Me Body and Soul” Pride and Prejudice Framed Quote

The Secret Garden Book Vase

Colorful Annotation Pens

Annotating Sticky Notes

Microwavable Lavender Filled Sloth

Late Fees at the Library Candle

Charles Dickens Clothbound Penguin Classics Box Set

Ralph Lauren Flag Sweater Dupe

Classic Raybans

Vineyard Vines Shirt

Book of Classic Style

Tennis Bag

Hydrangea Print

Ball Boy Candle

Personalizable Jewelry Box

Kate Spade Scalloped Crossbody

Floral Headband

The History of Wimbledon Book

Backgammon Set

Wooden Speaker/Phone Stand

Record Player

Guitar Pick Punch

Guitar

Personalized Cassette Tape Pillow

3D Puzzle Box

Vintage Horror Posters

Unsolved Mystery Kit

Retro Radio

Magnetic Fake Eyelashes

Silk Pillowcase

Tubing Mascara

Pom Pom Slippers

Professional Makeup Brushes

Replica Mini Perfume Gift Set

NYX Ultimate Eyeshadow Palatte

Milk Makeup Highlighter Stick

Rose Gold Lighted Makeup Mirror

Kosas Lip Fuel

Sparkly Drink Tumbler with Straw

Leather Bound Journal

Balancing Scales Display

Candleabra

Learn to Calligraphy Kit

Journal with Medieval Tapestry Cover

Purple and Green Switch Joysticks

Box of Japanese Snacks

Mini Fridge

Mini Scratch Art Notecards

Flat Umbrella for Bags and Backpacks

Sunset Lamp

Fidget Pen

Starface Pimple Patches

Collapsable Coffee Cup

Pocket for the Back of Your Phone

Tiny Bluetooth Speaker

Portable Phone Charger

Airpod Over-The-Ear Headphone Holders

Squishy House Slides

Tortilla Blanket

Lights and Clips for Photos

Colorful Jenga

Mini Tabletop Cornhole

Klask

Mini Bowling

Winter at Bow Bridge Puzzle

Jewish Baker Cookbook

Let’s Get Schmashed Sweater

Trivial Pursuit, Family Edition

House Slipper

Coach Crossbody Phone Case

Santal Scented Essential Oil

Colorful Stemless Glasses

NuFace Skin Firming Device

Filtration Showerhead

Cricut

Nugget Ice Machine

Reusable Eye Masks

Waterproof Canvas Tote

Back Massager

Jo Malone Perfume

Magnesium Supplement for Sleep

The Best Pens in the World

Scalp Massager

TheraIce Headache Hat

Universal Yum Snack Box

Ice Ball Maker

Solo Stove Pizza Oven

Keyboard Cleaning Gel

Scallop Pillows

Geometric Porcelain Bowls Set

Colorful World Coffee Table Book

Colorful Stemmed Wine Glasses

Iridescent Tissue Box Cover

Beachwaver Curling Iron

Rosemary Oil for Hair Growth

Ouai Leave in Conditioner

Act + Acre Scalp Care Oil

Storage + Ice Cube Tray

Colorful Set of Saucepans

Knife Sharpener

Momofuku Chili Crunch

Nespresso Milk Frother

Butter Bell

Chemix Pour Over Glass

Bowl Covers

Mini Holiday Le Cruset

Pan Scraper

Ninja Creami

Pasta Strainer

Cherry Measuring Cups Set

Cheese Knife

Apple AirTag Set

Super Easy Cookbook for Beginners

Hatch Restore Wake Up Light

Wine Glass Set of 6

Silver Belt Bag

Hanging Toiletry Bag

Wrangler Cup Holder and USB Charger Smart Suitcase

Reusable Travel Size Bottles

Plug-in Charging Pack

Packing Cube Complete Set

Folding Sunglass Case

Paula’s Choice Lip Booster

First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Intense Hydration Cream

Passport and Vaccination Card Holder

Hydroflask

Latte Larry’s Mug

Puddy’s Auto Repair Shirt (Seinfeld)

Live From New York: The History of SNL

The Waterboy Jersey

Schwety Blue Balls Gold Ball

Seinfeld Miniature Coffee Table Book of Coffee Tables

Sick in the Head by Judd Apatow

The History of Sketch Comedy

Anchorman Bust

Serenity Now Candle

Curb Your Enthusiasm Party Game

The Jokes in My Head Journal

More Cowbell Shirt

Seinfeld Party Game

The Little Book of Cottagecore

Vintage Style Crew Sock Set

Wildflowers Hanging Print

Waxed Canvas Reusable Tote

Ivory and Gold Floral Teacup Set

Wildflower Desk Lamp

Solo Stove Smokeless Fireplace

Resin Deer Wall Hanging

Needlepoint Kit

Twig + Moss Candle

Plant Propagation Bulb Station

Mushroom Incense Holder

Friends Reference Socks

Juicy Couture Tracksuit

Claw Clips

Soffee Shorts

Friends Mug

Friends Door Picture Frame

Jonas Brothers Tour shirt

Vera Bradley Tote

Portable CD Player

Life is Good Longsleeve Tee

North Face Puffer

Polaroid Camera

Harry Potter Makeup Brushes

Platfom Uggs

Samsung Cordless Vacuum

Last Call Candle

Bose Bluetooth Speaker

Hooded Robe

Vinyl Record Player

Mini Steamer

Accent Pillow and Throw Blanket Set

Vinyl Record Coaster Set

Flush Ritual Toilet Spray

Surfing Wetsuit

Diane Keaton Esque Hat

Coastal Coffee Table Book by Gray Malin

Cable Knit Sweater

White Wave Vase

Ghia Non Alcoholic Spritz

Travel Coffee Table Books

Powder Sunscreen

Mainstay Face Oil

Back Massager

6 Pack of Undershirts

Toaster Bags

Analogue Film Scanner

Make Your Own Hot Sauce

Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker

Popcorn Machine

4K HD Projector

You’re My National Treasure Mug

Emotional Support Coworker Keychain

Bento Box

Tiny Mic for Work Tiktoks

This Ain’t My First Rodeo Trophy

If you’d like to purchase something from The March Hare to support our shop in the East Village, click here to shop all the toys we have available online. You can also purchase a March Hare Holiday Surprise Gift Box which includes a main item of your choice and four smaller classic toy surprises for your child to find buried in the crinkle paper, along with a note from the March Hare Fairy. When the box arrives, you can wrap the entire thing and put it directly under the tree!

March Hare Holiday Surprise Gift Box

March Hare T-Shirt

March Hare Tote

Alright, that’s it! PHEW! Happy shopping and holidays! If you want to further support my holiday gift guide, please share it with your friends!

Julie says:

11/22/23 at 8:29 am

You just saved me a million hours of research- thank you!
Christina says:

11/22/23 at 10:05 am

For Jack’s past faves, there are two links for basketball free throw, and not one for what looks like a Brio pinball game?
JOdi says:

11/29/23 at 11:48 am

Absolutely incredible!!! Thank you!

The Biggest, Best Holiday Gift Guide for Absolutely Everyone On Your List in 2023!

3 responses to “The Biggest, Best Holiday Gift Guide for Absolutely Everyone On Your List in 2023!”