This past weekend, I was supposed to go on a sponsored trip with my family out of the country. It had been planned for months and plane tickets were booked. But as the day drew closer, I grew more conflicted about it and I decided to back out. I was scared to tell the sponsor because a contract had been signed and I was nervous to tell my husband because he was really excited for the trip.
But everyone understood. This weekend was not a normal weekend and we could not proceed as normal.
On the day of inauguration, watching Trump’s speech live with my co-workers in the office, I felt a sickening feeling in my stomach. I felt sad and frightened and I knew I needed to be around other people who felt sad and frightened too. I knew I had made the right choice to stay home.
Like millions of women, men and children across the country and around the world (3.3 million and counting!), I marched this past Saturday. I marched in NYC with about 400K people, almost as large as the march in DC.
I considered bringing Mazzy but was unsure whether she would appreciate the experience or whether I felt safe doing so. Ultimately, I gave her the choice. That morning, we turned on the television and watched the crowds form. The news had a split screen of DC, NY, Boston and Chicago and I could tell in Mazzy’s face that it all felt a little unsettling. “Can I stay home with Daddy and watch it on your Snapchat?” she asked. “Of course,” I responded, both disappointed and relieved. If you were watching my Snapchat of the March this past weekend, that wasn’t just for my followers, that was for Mazzy too.
I didn’t bring a sign or come with a huge group of people. I wasn’t prepared with a homemade cap or a chant. I just wanted to be present. When I was looking for what to wear that day, I couldn’t find anything pink and cursed myself for not being more organized. Then I realized I could find plenty of pink in Mazzy’s closet. Her hat and scarf fit perfectly. I went with my friend Emily, Emily’s mom Phyllis and my friend Lucy who came with her husband and their kids. We had pre-registered a few days before and got a time of 3pm (they were staggering start times), but aimed to get there at 2pm to find each other and scope out the scene. With a late start time, I was a little worried we would miss it. Oh, how naive I was then.
From the second I left my apartment in my pink hat, it was obvious there was energy in the air. People knew where I was going and I felt nods of approval as I walked down the street, passing others in pink or carrying hastily written signs by their sides. People who had obviously planned to go from the beginning and others who seemed more like they were compelled to go once it started.
The subway was packed. We waited as two full trains didn’t even stop to let more people in, before a third train arrived empty, seemingly just for us. Then we traveled uptown as the train became more and more packed at each stop. By the time we arrived at 51st Street, a massive wave of people exited together.
When we emerged from the subway, we saw hundreds of people marching west, all with signs held high. My friends and I were confused because we were several blocks away from the official start point.
“Did they reroute the march?” I asked someone passing by.
“No, there were so many people on 2nd ave. that no one was moving, so we decided to find a better spot to enter.”
My friends and I decided to make our way down to 2nd avenue anyway. The crowd was mostly at a stand still but it gave us time to take it in. We climbed scaffolding to get a good look and took pictures of people proudly holding up their homemade signs.
Although there were plenty of signs for women’s rights, there were signs for so many other things as well— black lives matter, gay pride, climate change, democracy, free press, immigration, public education, protection of our land and the list went on.
Yes, the people marching were angry with Trump and our new administration (as am I) but what I heard people chanting was more about what we are “for” than what we are “against.”
The march down 2nd ave was actually pretty quiet. It was packed with people (lots of women, but many men too, of all ages and ethnicities) but moved slowly and talked amongst themselves. Every once in awhile, there was a groundswell of cheers and a chant, but mostly, we were just admiring how such a diverse crowd had all come to be there together.
Then we hit 42nd Street and everything changed. As we turned down New York City’s most iconic street, you could suddenly see how massive the march was and how long it stretched. The crowd came alive in that moment and I think the fact that we were making history dawned on everyone. “This is what democracy looks like!” the crowd chanted.
We passed my old office building, where I had a job in my twenties. It is directly across the street from Mike’s old office building, where we worked at the same time, although only met years later. We both spent ten years of our lives going to work daily on that block. I took a 360 video of my location and texted it to Mike. “Look familiar?” it said. “Wow,” Mike texted back. We had never seen anything like this.
As we walked west on 42nd St, towards 5th ave where the march would turn again, it only gained momentum. The most amazing moment was when we hit Grand Central Station at about 5pm. It was twilight and all the lights has just been turned on, but the sky was still bright. It was magic hour, every photographer’s favorite time of day, and it felt like we hit the monumental moment of the march at exactly the right time. I’m not sure if everyone can understand what it felt like to have such a large crowd blocking the most trafficked area in Manhattan (not an area that the city would ever hold a parade), but there we were.
People were pouring out of Grand Central (as the always do) and being confronted with the march, even if they came into the city for other purposes. Cops and protest volunteers were gathered along the sidelines, smiling and greeting people like this was their day too. Behind me, a cop opened a barricade to let two women in. “Thank you, officer,” they said cheerily. “No, thank YOU,” he responded.
There is a small bridge that goes over 42nd Street and around Grand Central Station. Pedestrians are typically not allowed on it so it was quite a spectacle to see the people lined from one end to the other, across 42nd and up around the building, chanting to us, as we chanted back while heading underneath. “Tell me what democracy looks like!” the people on the bridge shouted. “This is what democracy looks like,” the crowd shouted back. It was a big, disruptive, energy filled moment and it is a feeling I hope I remember for the rest of my life.
When we reached the other side of the bridge, I turned around and saw Princess Leia marching toward me. Then a second Princess Leia rose. Up ahead a marching band started to play. It was celebratory and fantastic. The band was about fifty feet in front of us and my friend and I might have shimmied through a few people to catch up to them.
It was a band called the Hungry Marching Band and I have heard them play many times before. Back in twenties (and the might still do this now), they used to play late at night on the streets of the East Village. You’d be coming home from a bar at 3am when all of sudden you’d hear a tuba and trombone and an entire band turning a corner with late night revelers following behind like they were the Pied Piper. Every time I bumped into the band, it felt like I was witnessing something special. A quintessential downtown New York moment. It was always a sign of a good night. It felt so special to me that I got to march up 5th Avenue and complete the march behind them.
The day grew dark and the crowd only got bigger as we continued to march up past Rockefeller Center. “My body, my choice!” women yelled. “Her body, her choice,” the men in the crowd echoed back.
Then we marched straight up to 57th St. where Trump Tower loomed in the distance, a black glass building with barely any lights turned on. Trump wasn’t home, of course, and all the residents were either hiding or out there with us, but that’s the best thing about marching in this day and age. You don’t have to be there to see it. We know Trump was watching.
Say what you want about what Saturday’s march meant, but for me, it was exactly what I needed. It was therapeutic, it was inspiring, and it motivated me to think about what I will do next. On Saturday, I was not sad or frightened. I felt hopeful and powerful. It was exactly what I needed to move forward. Not “move forward” in the way that people say when they suggest we should “get over it” and “move on,” but move forward in a way that felt like together it’s possible to create real change.
I posted all day on Snapchat and Instagram and at some point, someone messaged me and said, “I can’t wait to read your recap on your blog.” Oh right, I thought. I will probably do a recap, which means there will be one more opportunity for my readers to support and criticize my stance.
It’s not easy posting about the current state of politics, especially if you have a large social media following that does not all agree. Like most social influencers, I don’t want to lose followers and I don’t like when comment sections under my posts get ugly, but I’ve come to understand that if that’s my sacrifice for getting the word out there, it’s a very small one to make.
I am so proud of my city. Of all the cities that marched peacefully on Saturday. I just hope the groundswell continues and that all the activists who marched, no matter their main cause, whether they have been doing this for years or they marched for the first time (like me), continue to work together for one common goal.
For those of you who want to know what’s next, here’s a link to the Women’s March official site where they have listed 10 Actions for the 1st 100 Days of Trump’s Presidency. Pretty smart of them making everyone register and getting that email list, huh?
You can follow Mommy Shorts on Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat and Twitter.
Did I mention I was up for a Shorty Award??!! Vote for me here.
So beautiful!! This post brought me to tears. Thank you for standing up and marching, and thank you for sharing.
Amazing!! Don’t ever be silenced by your audience!!!
I was one of the people who commented on your Instagram too and a fellow NYC marcher. It was an electric day and just re-reading about the chanting and energy gave me goosebumps again. I completely agree that it was the first time in a long time that optimism and a hope that there is conviction to change for the better was still alive and shared. I want to figure out a way to continue to channel that energy for what will undoubtedly be a very long couple of years ahead.
Thank you so much for sharing your experience!
I went to the march in D.C. and felt the same energy there. Don’t worry about the negative comments because WE ARE THE MAJORITY!
Thank you so much for sharing your experience. I was with a group of college students at a training that day. They were a diverse group and we had discussions about what was happening in the world. Their positivity was electrifying–just as I imagined the marches were. I have to believe that we will be the change we want to see in the world. We won’t be silenced. We won’t let our country take one step backwards.
Love this post. I took my spouse and kids to the Oakland march and it was great. We didn’t last the whole time (the kids are 3 & 6), but it was so important to do. And I am hoping my 6 year old will have some memories of standing up for kindness, hope, and determination.
We live in a world where we don’t have to agree about everything, and that includes politics. Thank GOD for that. I disagree with everyone marching. I disagree that “women are the future” and so forth. Women are not suppressed the way that they used to be, if they were, you couldn’t blog at all, because your voice would be suppressed. There are governments in this world that still do that and a woman blogger like you would be in jail or worse. We do not live in that country.
People who say “women are the future” are basically saying that women are more important than men. They are saying that their lives matter more than men’s lives. How about we say what should really be said which is ALL LIVES MATTER. Let’s stop labeling it with colors, religions, races, and creeds, and let’s start labeling it that ALL LIVES MATTER. I grew up in a mixed household and my stepfather never would have dreamed of this whole “Black Lives Matter” thing, why because he saw everyone equally, the way I see everyone. I dislike when people protest for a specific gender or race, it’s silly, why is your life anymore important than anyone else’s.
I ignored these protests. There was not a single sign that spoke for me. I have no desire to be a feminist, put women first, put black lives first, or any of these other ridiculous notions. I instead want to live in the country that I call home, the United States, without having to put up with people blocking roads and what is essentially mutiny.
Thanks for hearing me out. I know many will disagree
Sadly, unlike your stepfather, not everyone believes that we are all equal or that all lives matter. As this election has highlighted, there are still many people, including some of our elected officials, who believe that women, racial and religious minorities, immigrants, and persons with disabilities are not entitled to equal rights or dignities. When the president of the United States has maligned Mexicans and Muslims, mocked persons with disabilities, denigrated women, or when a man who has referred to an African American colleague as “boy” is the nominee for US Attorney General–how can we NOT march?? I don’t see it as “mutiny;” I see it as democracy.
If you’ve ever read the Koran, a book that much of the Muslim faith revolves around (not all Muslims, but there are many), it literally tells them to kill anyone who differs in beliefs from them and who is not a Muslim. Read it for yourself sometime, it will give you an amazing perspective on what is going on and why our government feels like they need to separate us from the Muslim community.
As for African Americans, I have seen both sides of the spectrum on that one growing up in a mixed household. The fact of the matter is that 93% of African Americans shot in this country are shot by other African Americans and they shoot in general 10 more times than the average white American does. They also get offended when someone calls them the “n” word, yet they go around yelling it at each other as a form of greeting.
It’s not that there is anyone race, religion, or anything else that is bad in this world. It’s that the world has changed dramatically and it’s not the world that our parents and grandparents grew up in. We see everything as it happens online, in real time, and it presents an information and news overload so people focus on what a few networks say rather than what the reality is. The media is skewed in many ways as is evident when they cover any news story. Look up any news story you want, and every media station you look up has a different fact or figure about it.
Society has lost respect for one another, not as a whole, but as a majority, and that has to change. I don’t think Trump knows a darn thing about politics, but I do think he knows a thing or two about business and how to run a business. Should the government be run like a big business? No, likely not. But it shouldn’t be run the way it’s been run for centuries either by politicians because it’s not working. The United States sends billions of dollars in aid to foreign countries yet lets our seniors and disabled suffer and live on mere pennies a month. It’s time to take care of our own and stop taking care of the rest of the world first.
I also think for people to judge the type of President Trump will be based on his actions when they haven’t even given him a chance is ludicrous. Why not see what kind of president he is first, and then protest if you don’t like it. Why protest something that hasn’t happened yet and a man who might turn out to be a half way decent president, despite the fact that his mouth needs a filter? (Which I totally believe he does by the way).
I love that Ilana’s blog is one of the few places where these types of discussions take place without anyone making threats or creating problems. The world is filled with opinions, it’s what makes the world go round. If we all had the same opinion, it would be a very boring world.
Excuse me but I find it very hard to believe you have read the Quran. The Quran does not say to kill or hurt anyone who doesn’t have the same belief. What it does say is that Muslims are bound to protect people of other religions. My husband is a Muslim and I am not though I have spent the past 13 years learning about it. You have no idea what you are talking about and you are actually dangerous because you are spreading misinformation and making statements that are just not true. I find it very disturbing that you are making false statements about something you know nothing about.
It’s not that black lives matter first, it’s that black lives matter too. Because very often, it feels like they don’t. I only offer this differing opinion for you to think about from the flip side, not to fight with.
That actually makes sense. Maybe they should change their signs to “Black Lives Matter Too” or ALL LIVES MATTER instead of just “Black Lives Matter” which to me sort of says the rest of the races are irrelevant and unimportant. The amazing thing is everyone in their lifetime will be prejudiced against sooner or later, whether they are black, red, purple, green, or white. That’s the way the world is these days, a world where people put themselves first and others last. It’s a sad, sad thing.
Thank you for opening up a dialogue. I think people get tripped up on semantics but the reason it’s “black lives matter” is because a lot of people seem to think Black Lives matter less. In a perfect world, yes, ALL lives matter but using that catch-all does not really address the real issue. Nobody is saying that Black Lives matter more or that women matter more. We are saying they should matter as much.
Also, you should pay attention to your last sentence: “That’s the way the world is these days, a world where people put themselves first and others last. It’s a sad, sad thing.” I agree. That is precisely the problem we all have with Trump. He puts himself first. He cares about America but not about the world. It is literally what he said in his inauguration speech. I know that people tend to put themselves first but I expect more from our president and the fact that he doesn’t think he even needs to pretend to care about others is a very scary scary thing. My family was in Germany in concentration camps during World War II and what this says to me is that if Trump was president, he would not have sent the US to help.
Ilana,
Your post is what opened the dialogue, amazing as always. While not everyone in this world agrees on everything, you don’t shove things down other people’s throats like some bloggers, nor do you cancel people’s subscriptions to your newsletters if they disagree with you (yes there are bloggers that do that). You are always tactful and graceful when you approach any subject, and that honesty is SOOOOO appreciated in today’s world.
I agree that Trump puts himself first. I would argue that he does not care about America. He cares about white, male, rich Americans. You and everyone that marched, marched to show Trump (and all his supporters and cabinet members) that there is more to America than white, rich males. To see all these marches, it made me proud of my country again after feeling shame and disbelief for many months (I currently live abroad).
I marched in Chicago on Saturday with my husband, my best friend from college, and her family (they drove down from Michigan). I agree, it was exactly what I needed. I was buoyed with hope seeing the immense crowds of people. When I was a senior in college (22 years ago), my women’s group marched on Washington DC as part of the the Rally for Women’s Lives and I think the crowd then was about 200,000. At the time that was the largest rally NOW had ever organized! And there was such a stigma attached to it. But to see 250,000 in Chicago and the millions of others from around the world — we have made such tremendous progress! So much progress in fact that people (like the commenter above) think there’s no more progress needed… but we know that’s not true as evidenced by the turnout across the world on Saturday. And as long as people like you and people like those that showed up Saturday, continue to make our voices heard, we’ll continue to make progress!
Thank you for this post. I live on the outskirts of L.A. and was really tempted to go to the march here, but my husband ended up working and my kids weren’t up for it (I’m not sure if I really wanted to take them anyway). But I watched the news all day and fell like I was *sort of* there in spirit. It was quite moving to see it all on tv across the world.
this was really moving. thank you for this recap!
Your post was beautifully written and I just want to thank you so much for sharing your experience with us.
Beautifully, beautifully written, as always. <3
Such a well written powerful recap of your experience. Thank you for sharing. I marched in my small town of approx. 90K. The media estimated there were 10K at our march downtown. I brought my almost 5 yr old daughter. We’ve discussed the issues at length since the election and she was super pumped to be part of the awe-inspiring day, feeling proud to be a girl. I couldn’t contain my pride in being her mama as she yelled “This is what democracy looks like” at the top of her lungs. It helped that this followed closely after MLK Day and our discussion about that. I have no doubt that we’ll both remember that day for the rest of our lives. Now I am working with other women friends, many of whom are moms, to not only be an active force in change, but to find ways to include our children in actions that are appropriate for them as well.
This post made me cry.. and I’d like to think it was more than just pregnancy hormones. I wish that I could of walked but I’m VERY pregnant and just couldn’t do it. So thank you for walking for my daughters and I. And thank you for standing up for your beliefs even when you know you are going to get crap for it. I don’t know how you do it!!??
Loved seeing your perspective. We were in the city on Saturday night visiting friends on the upper east side but we stayed on 57th street. My daughter is only 2 and my son 7 months so we weren’t involved in the march at all, but I’m excited for the day when they learn about the march in their history books and I can tell them they were there in NYC. We walked back to our hotel on 57th street after dinner and passed by the crowd chanting “my body my choice”, it was a very cool atmosphere (although the noise did wake the baby who was sleeping soundly in my carrier, oh well). Once we got up to our room, I watched as the crowd marched down 57th street below us. How cool.
I marched in Houston. I have never been moved to be politically active before. But at some point, we have to stop complaining and get up and do something. I marched on Saturday, I sent postcards to my senators, and I will continue to act. Because we cannot be silent and let injustice stand.
I love this. I especially love that one of your readers disagrees and everyone had a respectful discussion about it.
I went down to DC and had a very similar experience, and wrote a very similar blog post! Great minds…
Keep up the good work, Ilana.
Thank you for your recap and thank you for marching. My daughters and I are grateful for every single person who was able.
You really captured the spirit of the day with this heartfelt piece! And I loved your brave decision to go public with your stand. I hope every one of your readers supports you.
Thank you for this.
I was so thankful to be able to see the march in NYC through your snapchat and instagram. Thank you for marching and thank you for sharing your experience. I am very proud to be one of your readers!
Thank you for sharing this awesomesauce with us. I wish I could have been there.
I cried a little while reading about your experience. Thank you so much for always sharing what you really feel.
I marched in LA where the marchers reached 750k! It was, actually, a lot like how your experience read. My husband and I also marched for the first time. It was amazing how many people there were. We had to ride the metro in the wrong direction towards Santa Monica just to come all the way back and make it into downtown LA. Mayor Garcetti said there were 360k MORE riders than normal for a Saturday, totaling 592k riders… By the time we made it to the stop we had STARTED AT, the platforms were still overwhelmed with people. I loved hearing about the marches that took place in smaller cities throughout the US, especially considering how cold it was in so many other regions. It was an incredible moment for so many in the US, enjoyed both your posts.
What an amazing experience to remember for a life time!! Brought tears to my eyes and made me feel as though I was there marching along with you and the other 399,999+ people!! Great recap!
Thank you for recapping your experience – I loved watching your snapchat story on the day! I marched with three friends here in Melbourne, Australia and was heartened by the turnout, which was estimated to be over 6,000.
The negative effects of Trump’s presidency will not only be felt in the US, but worldwide. As one of the US’s major allies, many Australians know that we will be dragged into any conflicts Trump starts with world leaders who dare oppose him. Additionally, Australian political leaders take many of their cues from their American counterparts. Given we currently have a right-wing government that is full of wealthy white men lining their pockets and rorting the system whilst they implement anti-immigration, healthcare-cutting, climate-denying, anti-marriage equality policies, I shudder to think what they will try and get away with now.
On Nov 8 I was despairing at what was happening in the US and the world. On Jan 21, I began to hope again. Know that many in Australia share your views and are part of the resistance!
Thank you for this post and for standing up for what you believe in! I teared up reading this… especially after all the headlines today.
What an AMAZING post. Seriously, I alternated between getting chills and crying. Such a powerful movement, and you captured it beautifully. Thank you for all of your wonderful posts that highlight what you believe in. I’m with you!!!
Thank you for marching and for continuing to write posts about your political beliefs. You are making the right choice, and I value your integrity.
I sobbed the whole way through this post. It’s absolutely moving and inspiring to see so many people still remember what the real American dream is and still remember it’s always been great.
It’s been two weeks and I’m just now catching up on my blog feed. The constant deluge of bad news has been all consuming. Reading this was so helpful – to remember the power of that day. I lived in NYC during the Bush years and marched in New York and D.C. to protest the war. Two weeks ago I marched with 12,000 unapologetic social justice warriors in Oklahoma City, in my home state. 12,000! I could never have imagined that kind of turnout in such a deep red state. That crowd felt bigger than the 100,000 I marched with in D.C. because it felt so full of promise. I’m glad that I came back to this post today. Thank you for continuing to speak out and for using your platform to raise your voice.